< Podcasts

Ep 23: How Much Is Enough? Building the Right Emergency Fund


Cash may not be the most exciting part of your financial plan, but when the unexpected happens, it can quickly become one of the most important. Brian and Tracy break down how much to keep in emergency reserves, where to keep it, and how to decide what really counts as an emergency.

Episode Transcript:

Intro/Closing 0:02

Welcome to the Real Talk Retirement Show, where we explore the financial side of retirement and beyond. Whether you’re currently retired or planning for the future, we offer real, relatable conversations about money and personal finances. Most importantly, we dive into all these topics using Real Talk. Now, let’s get real about your money and your retirement.

Brian Graff 0:28

Welcome everyone to another episode of The Real Talk Retirement Show. We are Brian Graff and Tracy Burke from Conrad Siegel with you as always. Uh, Tracy, strap in because today we are going to talk about one of the least exciting investments you’ll ever make. Cash. Okay. Uh, you know, it’s one of those things, Tracy, where you don’t receive a statement saying, hey, congratulations, you beat the SP 500 this year. You know, it doesn’t have a ticker symbol to go along with it that you can brag to your friends about. And if you’re lucky, you’ll spend years wondering why you have all this money sitting around just doing nothing. But then your furnace dies in January, not a good thing. Your car’s transmission goes out, your company announces layoffs, or your roof decides it’s reached the end of its useful life. Suddenly that boring pile of cash becomes your favorite financial asset.

Tracy Burke 1:21

That’s right, Brian. So today we’re going to talk about that really exciting topic of emergency reserves. Again, how much you should have, where you should keep it, what actually qualifies as an emergency, and why having either too much or even too little, uh, certainly cash can both create problems. So, you know, if we think sort of some imagery here, Brian, of that emergency reserves is the financial equivalent of a fire extinguisher. You certainly hope you never need it, right? But when that catches on fire, boy, are you ever glad it’s there and ready for action. So uh if it sounds good, let’s jump in and figure out how much financial fire protection you might actually need.

Brian Graff 2:07

Yeah, so let’s start by defining it. What exactly is emergency reserves? Well, it’s money that is safe, liquid, accessible, and most importantly, available when you need it. The primary purpose of this money is really not to make a great return, it’s to provide financial flexibility when something unexpected happens.

Tracy Burke 2:28

Yeah, and Brian, I always think, you know, often think about having three purposes for emergency reserves. You know, the first one is to protect your lifestyle. So when, it’s really when, not if something goes wrong, right? And um, but you know, especially if you lose your income stream, and hopefully that doesn’t happen, but it it will at times, uh, if you lose that income stream, it does allow you to continue paying bills for a period of time. So again, protecting your lifestyle. The second purpose, I think, is protecting your investment portfolio. So during those tough times, if the investment markets aren’t doing well, it protects that, and and you don’t have to dig in and sell from your portfolio at potentially the wrong time. So, you know, imagine a stock market is down 20%, you lose your job or you need cash for something, then you just don’t have to dig in and sell from your portfolio at that so-called wrong time. And and then the third purpose, I would say, is a stress reliever, right? You know, the the studies are out there that financial stresses, you know, or finances really cause often the most stress in folks’ lives. So this is a big one and should be just that big relief to know when something does go wrong, you have options and you have some cash there. So going to sleep with a stash of cash for emergency certainly can be important.

Brian Graff 3:50

Yeah, 100%. And really the big question that everyone asks is well, how much do I need? How much should I have in emergency reserves? And really the traditional answer is usually somewhere between three to 12 months of essential living expenses. But as with many answers in our financial planning industry, we typically add, well, you know, it really does depend. So what are some of those potential factors, Tracy?

Tracy Burke 4:16

Yeah, and you know, a lot of people think, or I think especially three to 12 months, that’s a really a wide range, right? But but here are some of those factors, I would say, you know, the stability of your current income. So somebody that has highly predictable, very steady income, security within their job, uh, especially a two-household income, um, you know, or two-income household, I guess is probably the better way to put it, you know, likely will need less than somebody with the opposite, somebody that’s maybe self-employed, maybe somebody that’s you know, volatile, commission-based type of an income. Uh, you know, maybe they’re in a highly volatile position or just have one income in their household. Um, you know, another factor I think uh, you know, along that same lines is the circumstance within your within your household, of course, you know, the number of family members. So if you have one kid versus 13 kids, um, you know, something along those lines who who are dependent on you, if you have aging parents. Um, so again, some people have different or specific financial obligations they have to think through. Um, another factor comes to mind is, you know, how much you spend uh that’s that’s really labeled as essential versus discretionary. Um, you know, those essential expenses, something uh the ones that are recurring, that those uh are important versus discretionary, something the more the fund spending. So if you know, if a person has $4,000 a month of essential expenses, that’s gonna be a much different need, of course, than somebody that spends, say, $12,000 a month on essential needs. But again, figuring out that essential versus discretionary, uh, because while it should be easier to cut back on the discretionary budget during hard times, it’s as we know almost impossible to cut down on the essential spending. Things like your mortgage or rent payments, uh, utility costs, food, transportation, those are just ones that you maybe a tiny bit of flexibility, but most of the time not.

Brian Graff 6:20

Yeah, and your insurance protection is also a factor, Tracy. So if you have excellent health insurance, disability insurance, homeowners, auto, you’re likely going to have less exposure to certain financial emergencies. So make sure your uh your insurance coverages are where they should be. And again, just a reminder the best practice is to have somewhere between three to 12 months of your expenses in emergency funds. But all of those items we just discussed factor into a more precise amount that’s appropriate for your situation.

Brian Graff 6:49

So now let’s transition to where you should keep those funds. So, Tracy, back to you.

Tracy Burke 6:55

Yeah. So, Brian, I would say it’s it’s important to start with the concept that not all cash is necessarily for emergency reserves. So if we break down in into buckets here, um the first bucket is really just like the regular checking account, the ins and the outs that covers your monthly bills, your near-term spending. Um, so that’s your cash flow, the in and out. Uh, bucket two, I would then argue, should be what we’re talking about today. This is your cash savings or your emergency reserves that are there when it’s needed. So again, job loss, you know, major home or vehicle repair, cost, unexpected medical uh expenses, uh, or other financial emergencies. Um, then bucket three, some people have a third bucket and some people don’t. And I would so I would say it’s optional. Um, and but you know, it’s really for things that you know or want to plan for, it’s coming down a pike. So maybe you’re you’re trying to save for a new car. You you’re not saving for a new car in your checking account. You’re not saving for the new car as part of your emergency reserves. You’re saving intentionally for it in really the third bucket. Uh, could the same thing for home renovation, uh tuition, you know, uh college savings, of course, that can be a big one. Uh, a lot of people have a bucket for vacation savings that they’ll save intentionally for vacations, uh, weddings for kids, you know, and really any big ticket item. So, but again, as I mentioned, that middle bucket, sort of that bucket two, so to speak, in this example, that’s the place to stash your cash for financial emergencies. So, Brian, you know, I think the next thing to think about, you know, are some other important things that that might come to mind. So, uh, what what were you thinking?

Brian Graff 8:41

Yeah, so when it comes to your emergency reserves, again, those those three things, Tracy, that come to my mind, and the following order of importance would be number one, safety, really meaning that with this money, there is zero chance that you lose your investment value. So we want to be safe. We do not want to take risks with this money. Uh, liquidity is the second one, meaning that you you’re able to access the money whenever you need it, whenever that emergency comes up right away. Uh, and then finally, yield, which is the rate of return you get on that money or the interest that you’ll receive on the investment. So, again, just keep in mind your emergency reserves isn’t the place where you’re chasing the highest possible return. Safety and availability are the most important things. So, let’s just go over some possible places to keep that money with those important factors in mind. So, first we have our traditional bank savings account. Super easy to administer. You know where your money is, uh, but it likely has the lowest interest rate associated with that option. The second thing would be a high yield savings account. Certainly, certainly gaining a lot of popularity uh in this uh day and age. With those high yield savings accounts, you know, they’re often found online and they definitely provide typically a better interest rate while maintaining liquidity. So if you decide to go in that direction, make sure you’re considering such things like FDIC insurance, which does have a $250,000 limit, any fees or minimum balances associated with that product, and any withdrawal or transfer limitations or even possible rate changes. So make sure, bottom line, you read the fine print when you set up that high yield savings account. Then you have a money market deposit account at a bank, which uh, you know, a good thing is about that, it’s also FDIC insured and usually pays a higher rate than your traditional bank savings account. Okay. And finally, you have what we call money market mutual funds. These are likely part of a brokerage account, but they can also provide liquidity and more competitive or higher yields uh than previous options.

Tracy Burke 10:47

Yeah, and Brian, I would say it’s important to note to our listeners that this last one you just mentioned, that money market mutual fund at a brokerage firm, is not the same thing as the one you mentioned right before, which was the money market deposit account. Uh a lot of times we hear the terms money market and we equate them to meaning the same things. But it’s easy to confuse them as being the same. But the money market mutual fund, the last one you mentioned at a brokerage firm, will usually have a higher interest rate, but it’s also not FDIC insured, uh, although very stable and and there’s generally should not be any problems and historically has not.

Brian Graff 11:27

Yeah, great point, Tracy. And you know while the options we just mentioned are the most common choices, you know, some people may even use like shorter-term treasury bills, but you know, liquidity component does make that a little bit more complicated. So be careful there.

Tracy Burke 11:40

Yeah, for sure. So something else that I was thinking of that I would love to emphasize is that the emergency reserve should not be invested. And when we say invested, and we’ll we’ll we’ll clarify that here a little bit, but you know, a lot of times people will say, Well, I have you know enough in my brokerage account or my 401k or other retirement accounts to cover any of these unanticipated needs. And that always, you know, I think makes us in industry, right, Brian, cringe uh when we hear that, you know, because those assets aren’t safe, they’re not liquid, and they’re not accessible, which are some of those factors you just mentioned a couple of minutes ago uh from that perspective. So in your brokerage or a retirement account or those investment accounts, your goal is really to maximize your long-term return. And of course, as you know, everybody’s hearing here, the goal for emergency reserves, that that’s not the goal. It’s it’s much different. So, you know, we we hear sometimes people say, well, I’m just gonna keep my emergency reserves in bonds. And I would argue that’s normally not a good idea because it just like stocks, bonds can lose value. Uh, more often than not, they don’t, but they can lose value. And hate to sort of break the news to people that might not be aware. But here is we’re recording this in fairly late 2026, bonds are actually negative, slightly negative uh total returns so far this calendar year. Um, so again, bonds are not equivalent to cash. Uh, while bonds sometimes, especially the shorter term bonds, are are quite stable and rarely lose value. It is certainly possible during certain economic times. So, again, that cash position is what to use for emergency reserves. And then one last thing is never ever treat a credit card as the emergency fund. You know, that’s always a bad idea.

Brian Graff 13:32

That’s such a bad idea, Tracy. It’s worth repeating. Never treat a credit card as an emergency fund. It’s just going to get you in trouble.

Brian Graff 13:40

So, Tracy, let’s address uh a pivotal concept. What actually constitutes a financial 911 or an emergency?

Tracy Burke 13:49

Yeah, this is super important, Brian. You know, so if if I receive an email from Amazon today saying today only, that’s not an emergency. You know, that’s of course marketing, right?

Brian Graff 13:59

That that is for sure true. Yet, you know, some people do interpret emergencies in different ways. So I’m gonna go out on a limb here, but let’s uh let’s break it down. So, first we’re gonna look at legitimate emergencies like a job loss, major medical expenses not covered by insurance, major unexpected home or vehicle repairs. And I want to emphasize here the unexpected portion with that. This is not simply doing a home renovation or buying a new car. Those are things you save separately for. And then other unexpected, just family financial emergencies in general. The following things I would say are likely not legitimate emergencies, and that would be, again, the great deal on vacations or a sale at your favorite retailer, new TV, golf clubs, or you know, other fun items, you know, work those into your regular budget. We’re not saying to take them off your plate completely, but definitely not emergencies, right? So also I would mention a new car, big ticket items, you know, again, stuff you should save separately for.

Tracy Burke 14:58

Yeah, absolutely. So another common question that that sometimes can be a debatable one, and it makes, you know, rightfully so, is you know, people that say, I’m in retirement. Do I still need an emergency fund? So, you know, this is not always an easy answer. And actually, a lot of financial you know professionals actually disagree on that very answer. So here would be my opinion. You know, retirees don’t necessarily need a special emergency reserve bucket like the when in your working years you you do. And, you know, why at you know, why not you ask? It’s it’s you know, those working are dependent on that paycheck to cover expenses. And retirees, of course, are not. If as long as they’re in good financial shape, of course, retirees have that effective retirement income stream coming from combination of some uh you know income sources, some of those guaranteed income sources like Social Security, and maybe some still have a pension. And then, of course, the ones, you know, the withdrawals from the retirement or investment portfolio when in retirement. So I’m certainly not opposed to a retiree maintaining that emergency reserve bucket. And they should always have that sleep well at night cash position in a bank. But if an emergency comes down to pike, they’re likely better positioned to handle it uh from their portfolio retirees, that is. Uh, just another reason, as we’ve talked in in past times, you know, don’t ever be invested in 100% stocks and have bonds in your portfolio that you can likely tap in. And we did talk about, you know, sometimes bonds aren’t always stable either when the stock market is down. But I would emphasize also the appropriateness of cash. Um, we’ve said this before, cash is not a good long-term investment, but it is important to keep an appropriate amount of cash in your particular situation. Um, you need enough during your working career for that emergency fund. But keep in mind, again, it’s not that long-term investment. We know that inflation normally goes up, probably the same or even more often than cash uh you know, returns on cash, so to speak. Um, and again, the goal isn’t to have as much cash as possible. The goal is just simply to have enough cash that you don’t have to worry about having cash.

Brian Graff 17:19

Absolutely great stuff, Tracy. And you know, as we always do with these podcasts, let’s finish with some action items that our viewers can take with them. So these are important. So we’d encourage you to carve out a little time in the next week or so to consider these. Uh, number one, first action item, calculate your number. Take your essential monthly expenses and multiply them by the appropriate number of months, again, likely somewhere in that three to 12 month range. Uh, then the second thing would be to separate your buckets. Remember, we talked about those three different buckets operating cash in your checking account, emergency reserves and some sort of savings or money market type account, and then planned expenses, items you’re saving for in an appropriate savings vehicle. Then confirm where your money is held is the best place for you. Is it earning a reasonable rate? Is it FDIC insured? And how quickly can you access it? What else do you have, Tracy?

Tracy Burke 18:13

Yeah, so you know, also stress testing your household. Um, you know, if you ask yourself the question, if my paycheck didn’t come through this week, how long could we maintain our current lifestyle? And then also ask, you know, what if I needed to come up with $20,000 for that new roof or furnace? Could I handle that? So if you don’t have adequate emergency reserves, I would say, first of all, you’re likely not alone, right? Many people are in that position, but it’s critical to take action. Uh, try not to be overwhelmed. It’s okay to start small and really build from there. So automate building up those emergency reserves. You know, budget, find up money, establish that automatic monthly transfer into the emergency reserves, just like you’re saving for retirement. Uh, but get that uh, you know, uh happening automatically and then just manage it. Uh, if you need to tap into emergency reserves, then just do your best to rebuild it as quickly as you can in the shortest amount of time that you have. And then finally, I would say, you know, just have that mindset that emergency reserves should be a permanent part of your financial plan. Just like other financial items, it’s important to plan for it.

Brian Graff 19:26

All right, Tracy, excellent. Great stuff. And, you know, I think the important thing to end on is the importance of just starting. You know, if you do your homework and you do the calculation of, you know, what six months of my essential living expenses? What does that equate to, you know that calculate to? It could be a big number. So try not to get intimidated by that. Don’t put your head in the sand, start small. You know, get a get a thousand dollars in there and start start working from there. But like so often we say in our industry, especially when it comes to saving for retirement, you know, the most important thing you can do is to simply get started.

Brian Graff 19:59

And then, of course, you know, reach out to us if you have any questions uh or comments. You can reach us at podcast at conradsiegel.com. We are here to help. Uh, and then please share this podcast with your families, friends, coworkers, and you know, even consider giving us a five-star review or subscribe if you haven’t already. But thanks so much, everyone, uh, for staying with us on your journey to and through retirement. We’ll see you next time on the Real Talk Retirement Show.

Intro/Closing 20:28

Thank you for tuning into today’s show. The Real Talk Retirement Show is created and produced by Conrad Siegel, an advisory firm that specializes in helping people prepare for retirement and beyond. If you want to learn more about our work or meet the team, you can visit conradsegal.com. Information on this show is for educational purposes only and should not be considered personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. Before making decisions, you should consult with the appropriate professionals for advice that is specific to your situation.